Over Payment Scams: What Seniors Need to Know to Stay Protected

December 2, 2025

Over payment Scams

Scammers are always coming up with new ways to trick people out of their hard-earned money—and unfortunately, seniors are often targeted. One of the latest and most deceptive scams involves scammers telling seniors they owe money due to an "overpayment" and pressuring them to send funds immediately. But here’s the catch: victims are often made to believe they entered a smaller amount than what they actually sent, causing them to lose far more than intended.

How the scam works

The scam usually starts with a call, email, or text from someone pretending to be from the government, a bank, or another trusted agency. The scammer might claim you’ve been overpaid Social Security, VA benefits, or taxes, and now you need to "pay back" the excess amount right away.

If you try to send the money, the scammer uses tricks to confuse you into sending more than the supposed overpayment. They may tell you that the amount you sent wasn’t enough, or that you accidentally entered the wrong number, so you need to send more. Sometimes, they ask you to repeat the payment several times, draining your accounts.

Why It’s So Dangerous

This scam plays on fear and urgency, making seniors feel pressured to act quickly to avoid legal trouble or losing benefits. The scammers often demand untraceable payment methods like wire transfers, gift cards, or cryptocurrency, which makes recovering the money almost impossible.

Protect Yourself and Your Loved Ones

Stay calm and don’t rush. No legitimate agency will demand immediate payment without proper paperwork or the chance to appeal.

Verify the claim. Contact your bank or the agency directly using known phone numbers to confirm if there’s any real over payment or debt.

Avoid unusual payment methods. Never send money via gift cards, wire transfer, or cryptocurrency at the request of a caller.

Final Thoughts

These over payment scams can leave lasting financial damage—but knowing what to watch for is your best defense. If something feels off or the caller is pressuring you for immediate payment, pause, verify, and get help. Protect your peace of mind and your wallet by staying informed and cautious.